Would you rather Realize the prank caller has been calling from inside your house or Realize you're not actually alone in your house tonight?
So far, 40% of players chose the first option and 60% chose the second, out of 104,053 votes. Make your pick below to add yours and reveal the live results.
OR
More Horror dilemmas
Watch a horror movie alone at midnight, in the dark or Watch a horror movie with friends, but have to walk home alone after?Be given a warning about something bad that's about to happen, but it's vague or Get no warning at all, but it turns out fine in the end?Be stuck in an elevator with a silent stranger or Be stuck in an elevator completely alone, with the lights flickering?Have a recurring nightmare you can never escape or Have a nightmare that follows you into reality for just one day?Discover a hidden passage behind a bookshelf in your home or Discover your house has a basement you never knew about?Hear something scratching at your window at night or See a figure standing across the street, just watching, then it's gone?