Would you rather Wake up at 3 a.m. to a strange noise downstairs or Wake up at 3 a.m. to find your bedroom door open, even though you closed it?
So far, 67% of players chose the first option and 33% chose the second, out of 129,395 votes. Make your pick below to add yours and reveal the live results.
OR
More Horror dilemmas
Live in a house that's definitely haunted, but the ghost seems friendly or Live in a house that might be haunted — you're just never sure?Hear something scratching at your window at night or See a figure standing across the street, just watching, then it's gone?Hear footsteps behind you on an empty street at night or Hear a voice whisper your name in an empty house?Discover a hidden passage behind a bookshelf in your home or Discover your house has a basement you never knew about?Spend the night in an abandoned hospital or Spend the night in an abandoned amusement park?Watch a horror movie alone at midnight, in the dark or Watch a horror movie with friends, but have to walk home alone after?